Tuesday, February 3, 2026

True Detective S1E1/2

I watched S1E1 and most of E2, many years after doing the same; I remembered very little.

What a great show. Between GoT and True Detective, HBO in 2014 was like Athens in 400 BC, where popularity and quality somehow coexist in the same objects, and those objects are multiple, making that locale an exciting place to be.

Woody Harrelson is decent as a deliberately archetypal cop bro. Matthew McConaughey is far more compelling as an almost byronic antihero: aloof, brilliant, dark, misunderstood. I wonder if he'll take a Jaime Lannister heartfelt heroic turn, or a Heathcliff free fall. Based on the foreshadowings, I guess he ends up wasting away somewhat. Either way, his performance is classic.

This show has strong characters and a strong atmosphere: all it needs for true greatness, other than continued execution, is an intriguing plot. So far, the leads they're chasing are a little dull. It doesn't feel like Sherlock where you as the viewer are on the edge of your seat for the solution. I would love to see this case get more intriguing, as opposed to the series just being a character study. If that happens, the initially dull leads will make sense.

I also just love McConaughey's aesthetic. Thin without being skinny, tall enough, clean yet shaggy haircut, looking old enough to look weathered and young enough to look athletic, smartly dressed yet the tie is loose and nothing is stiff, always a dark brow

8 comments:

  1. Seems like you didn't continue on to E3?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not yet at least. Debating what to do with this

      Delete
    2. I guess it's too late now... I've been thinking about rewatching S2

      Delete
    3. My years-long accidental free trial loophole of HBO seems to have run out. They finally kicked me out. I'll have to consider what to do about House of the Dragon though

      Delete
    4. wow HOTD on S3 already. Just looked up cast and hardly recognize anyone. only Olivia Cooke and Rhys Ifans

      Delete
    5. Dude from Caught Stealing has an interesting role as a Targaryen. But yeah the show is fairly obscure. Kinda hard to justify

      Delete
    6. Hated that guy. He looks inbred so at least that's on brand

      Delete
    7. Oh he's perfect for the role. GOT sort of sweeps Targaryen incest under the rug, but this guy in HOTD bears the torch

      Delete