Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Pattinson Bond

Pros:

  • famous = easier to get excited about
  • relatively tall and thin
  • bleak features, dark energy
  • looks suave
  • Cedric Diggory is dear to us
Cons:
  • cold, bleak personality
  • not actually as attractive as people seem to think (go ahead, look up photos right now)
  • unconvincing in The King
  • unconvincing in The Lighthouse
  • unconvincing in The Odyssey
  • unconvincing in Water for Elephants
  • unlikable in The Batman
I'm excited about it, and I want his shadowy brooding to work. But I'm not convinced he's magnetic enough nor actually a good actor. I'm thinking he'll turn out like Ansel Elgort in West Side Story, too moody and modern for that spotlight.

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Harry Potter titles

I'm on the fifth book, observing how the titles don't always reflect the most salient subjects.

Proposed titles for the four I've read:

  1. Harry Potter and the He's a Wizard
  2. Harry Potter and the Mindfuck Anagram
  3. Harry Potter and the Animagi, the Hippogriff, the Dementors, and the Time Turner (this book is extra plotty)
  4. Harry Potter and the Child Murder Tournament

Now I'm on the sixth book, and here's another way to look at it:
  1. Harry Potter and the Wizard School
    1. because wizard school is the basic premise of the series that's introduced here
  2. Harry Potter and the Plot Thickens
    1. because everything gets really dark and knotty, and that's the fundamental shift from the first book's essence of "wizard school"
  3. Harry Potter and the Tri-Turn Wizardment
    1. because Hermione turns the Time Turner three times, and this book has about three major plot twists. And because it's a pun on the next book.
  4. Harry Potter and the Triwizard Tournament
    1. because the tournament defines the tone and plot of this book
  5. Harry Potter and the Long Suffering
    1. because it's the longest and grimmest book, and that's its defining feature

louis ck ridiculous

Drafted a few months ago:

he makes things not sound like jokes, just sound like standup. that's how pure and essential to the craft he is
sometimes he drags out the craft too much though. it's too convoluted and unnatural. sometimes he needs to just chat, like he used to. it's too carefully planned
like when he said "i know this kid that's 11" i knew he was about to stop the story to say something about knowing an 11 year old. his excessive crafting is getting predictable.

Monday, September 14, 2026

Obsession

I haven't seen a lot of horror, but I wonder why every one I've seen is so uniformly plastic in character and dialogue? Do I just happen to watch satirical horror? Is it elemental to the genre that character and dialogue are shallow, as a convoluted way of juxtaposing or justifying the depth of the terror? Are horror writers just garbage at those other screenwriting tenets?

Obsession wasn't the worst version of this problem, but it was off-putting in this way. My bar is set at realistic human interaction, even if the situations to which the humans respond are not realistic. I want to see people respond as people would respond. In fact, I seem to prefer movies with unrealistic situations; but the human response has to feel real. There's no way the Obsession characters would interact like they did in this movie, even if the supernatural element were natural. And I don't think it's just an analytical matter for me, I think it also feels fake. It's cringey and frustrating.

Obsession was a nice middle-ground between all-out horror and bright, relatable movie. I don't think horror is generally a good genre for me, but this one didn't go too deep. It wasn't too disturbing. And it had some thoughtful elements to balance out the fear.

It was a fun watch, but not a very impressive movie. I'm not sure why it was so successful; I guess because it hit that middle ground I mentioned.

I really disliked the main character, in every way. His physical presence made me uncomfortable, and his actions were continuously questionable. That he hung around for so long, without seeking a solution or fleeing, can't be excused. I'm sure this lack of likability serves a narrative purpose, though I think it also just made me enjoy the movie less.

Tuesday, September 1, 2026

Memento

Memento has been lurking on my lists for over a decade. I think I saw it once, in high school or college, but I always wondered if I missed something. At the same time, I gradually lost interest. It feels good to check it off, definitively, now, and it feels good to have liked it. It feels good not to grow more and more resentful of Christopher Nolan.

This might be the movie of his that I can dislike the least. Not that I really dislike any of his movies -- but they all have things I dislike, all except Memento. This is the most solid, least problematic Nolan movie I've seen. Even Interstellar, my favorite of them, is totally gross at times. Half the time I find myself talking about it, I'm mocking it. Memento, though, gives me nothing to tease, other than perhaps Guy Pearce's hairdo. But that's just the era. Writing-wise, it's the mellowest affair, the modest one, brainy without being flashy, noir instead of superheroes/astronauts/demigods/time-travelers/dream-stealers. It's just a guy with a condition. It's high-concept (like Tenet) without losing its humanity (unlike Tenet). Now, I actually like the fantastical premises of his flashier movies, but I don't like how they translate to flashy, superficial characters+dialogue. I want Nolan to blend his cerebral plots with fantastical settings AND down-to-earth dialogue. He's yet to achieve that, in my memory, but Memento is one of the more successful balancing acts. As far as making a solid movie, I'd take authentic writing over flashiness, even if, for making a memorable movie, I'd take the flashiness. In that sense -- appropriately -- Memento isn't his most memorable movie, other than the fact that it was maybe his breakthrough (so it felt flashier at the time). It's like Reservoir Dogs, which isn't Tarantino's flashiest, but is a landmark and a breakthrough. In fact, it's a lot like Reservoir Dogs...

I wish they could have gotten Brad Pitt as they apparently proposed. I can't confirm that I've seen Guy Pearce in anything else, and he doesn't quite have the presence to make this all work. He's just a Guy.

Saturday, August 29, 2026

The Pillars of the Earth

I watched about 1.2 episodes. It was strangely boring, for a book so enthralling. I wonder if that's because I just finished the book, hence nothing can be surprising, or because the miniseries is a lifeless staging of the plot, nothing more. Maybe it gets better; I mean, the first episode (an eighth of the series) rushed through at least a quarter of the book. Was it intentionally preliminary to what could be the real focus of the miniseries, Jack's ascension? Or is this whole shebang perfunctory?

Casting
Eddie Redmayne isn't a bad choice, since he's a reputable actor with a handsome/ugly factor. He's too handsome for young Jack, and too ugly for older Jack, but he's not a bad pick to split the difference. Nevertheless, he's not Jack to me, and I bet re-reading the book would revitalize my prior image of Jack rather than being superseded by Eddie Redmayne. I'm glad of that, and it doesn't reflect well on that casting.
Waleran is too old and tired. He needs to be sharp as a knife. This is a clear miss.
Ellen is not attractive or hypnotic enough. She must be startling to behold, only partly because of beauty. I'm imagining Zendaya in Dune -- her eyes are almost scarily blue, she's dark-toned and agile. Ellen needs to be older and golden-eyed instead, but the vibe itself would work.
Why would you drop Aliena's big dark curls? Just do the curls, man.
Matthew Macfayden is a reasonable option. He's maybe a little soft, but I'd have to watch the whole series to see how it pays off.
The biggest blunder is Tom Builder. It's so bad, I don't know why, but I knew it was bad the moment I saw him on the cover of the DVD. First, when I actually got to watching it, I saw he lacked personality. He should be warm and lovable. Second, I don't know what to say about his looks, other than they're wrong. It looks nothing like the Tom Builder I imagined. He's too dark, not big and bushy enough.

It's so strange that I'd never heard of this miniseries until researching the book last year. With this star power, and such a quality story, either I'm really under a rock in terms of TV or this thing just isn't that good. After one episode, I'm thinking it's one of those weird works that's good on paper and doesn't really do anything wrong other than lack a soul. It's functional, and it emotionally fails. [Obvious AI parallel here]

Tar

I can't join all of this Tar worship.

First, Blanchett irritated me. I think she did well overall, but she could have been amazing, if she'd acted like a real person instead of an Oscar-groping actor. I noticed this immediately, in her articulation during the early interview. The script was realistic enough -- amazingly -- but her delivery was not. I can't get behind such a lauded performance that starts so rocky. This continued through the Juilliard class and various other scenes: she had impressively down-to-earth lines to deliver, and she delivered them like a stage actor overthinking her theatrics. She had a lot of good moments; her worst moments were when she was trying to be professional and refined. I couldn't see the character's thought processes in her dialogue, I could only see that the actor already had the words behind her mouth, and was overthinking how to convey them.

Second, it just didn't level me like it needed to. It was open-ended without inspiring meditation, heartbreaking without inspiring heartbreak, frightening without being scary; in short, these worthwhile characteristics just didn't hit as hard as they should have. It's always uncomfortable to admit that an artwork very fine in form yet fails to fulfill its purpose, but that was Tar for me. Perhaps if I was more sensitive to issues of homosexuality, femininity, fame, or classical music, I would have felt differently.

Actually, as far as the music bit, I think I'm in the sweet spot: I'm musical enough to understand most of what's going on without being so refined in classical music that I could spot every inauthenticity. I'm refined enough in some things that I've hit that latter point in other movies (jazz in La La Land, physics in Interstellar, etc) but I should have been in a good position for Tar. I do think the music-related writing was strong; it just didn't hit me all that hard in the end.

I also never loved nor loathed Lydia. I didn't accept that she was a predator until just after the movie finished (I can be slow with these things), though I could see she was flying off the rails a while earlier and I therefore didn't support her. Perhaps this movie would have been more intense had I been more invested in or intimidated by her.

Okay, I don't think the movie was bad at all. Field was surgical with his writing and direction. The story was engrossing. I thought about it after it was over. I like and respect this movie. I just have to respond to any movie's general reception when my experience strays, and in this case that means slight disappointment.

Edit:
Okay, I gained some new insight. Apparently interviews are often scripted in the real world, hence not only was Cate Blanchett scripted when interviewing as Tar, Tar herself was scripted! That makes Blanchett's uncanny rigor in the way she speaks more forgivable. Had I known that, I might not have been biased against the performance from the start, and I might have treated future scenes of unnatural dialogue more sympathetically. I know that Blanchett as Tar has a forced way of speaking even outside the probably-scripted interview (Juilliard class, when she talks to her orchestra, other settings of attempted poise), but I might have found other reasons for these if I hadn't written her off so early based on incomplete information. Maybe all of this unnatural dialogue is accurate for the character, who is basically living a lie: Linda Tarr of Staten Island, unstable predator, is posing as perfect Lydia Tar. I'm not totally convinced, but I can see how that could lend more credit to Blanchett's work.
    As far as not knowing interviews are often scripted in the real world... I haven't seen lots of interviews, so I'm used to the raw spontaneity of such things as Norm Macdonald on Conan, or David Foster Wallace on Charlie Rose. These are uncomfortably authentic. So Blanchett as Tar's scripted version of herself just came off as inauthentic acting on Blanchett's part, when it may just be inauthentic acting on Tar's part.