Wearing only the humblest artistic skin, the crux of Manchester by the Sea is the viewer's individual ability to connect to the story and the characters -- the human element, not artistic. I liked the characters, the setting, the atmosphere -- but for me this was a very mild experience. I can't denounce the film, nor can someone with a stronger experience celebrate the film; it's good, and not much more can be said. I wish I could say more about the artistry, since it's that element on which I want to focus in film nowadays. But the writing and acting really weren't special, despite their probably being the basis for this film's praise.
This is an unsuccessful blend of Hollywood and independent cinema, of vague comedy and vague drama. It's a fine movie that just doesn't do enough.
I haven't seen this yet but your post seems to strike right at the heart of the film, I appreciate the concise insight of this post.
ReplyDelete